Assault With a Deadly Weapon
Assault with a deadly weapon is an aggravated of assault and it is considered a wobbler offense in California, which means that the crime could be charged in Court as a misdemeanor or a felony.
For someone being convicted of Assault with deadly weapon, under California Penal Code §245 (a), the prosecution must prove the following requirements:
- The defendant's conduct must have been acted in a circumstance that would result in force upon another person.
- The conduct was acted with a deadly weapon, or would most likely produce a great bodily injury.
- The action was made with wilful intention
- The defendant was aware that the conduct would likely cause offensive or harm of another person.
- The use of a deadly weapon was would likely to harm another person.
For a better understanding, it will be explained all the requirements for this type of charge.
Uses of force
The uses of force is the same meaning as a simple assault, so long as there is an offensive or harmful touching, which is caused in an aggressive way, it could be considered an use of force. It is important to state that even if there is no intention of the defendant to cause injury, the prosecution might still charge with assault with deadly weapon.
Example (1): James, a 15 years old boy, got into a playground fight with Kevin and threw a rock at him. The rock did not get close to Kevin and did not cause any harm.
However, the prosecution could considered assault with deadly weapon if it is enough evidence to convince the jury that a rock could be a deadly weapon.
California Courts already established that a deadly weapon object is an instrument that could be used that is likely to cause serious harm to another. The questions raised more often from clients is: what is considered a deadly weapon, beside firearms and obvious objects using inherently to cause deadly weapons?
The main issue to consider an instrument a deadly weapon is whether the object is likely to produce death or great bodily injury. So, the element that is going to define whether an instrument is a deadly weapon or not, it is the manner that specific object was used.1
A defendant used a pencil to threat and stab the victim. And courts considered any type of hard, sharp, pointy thing that could be use to threaten someone a deadly weapon instrument.2
To determine whether an object is inherently deadly the evidence must consider the following factors:
- The nature of the weapon
- The manner of its use
- The location of the injuries inflicted
- The extent of these injuries.3
This means, it would be considered deadly weapon a potentially dangerous objects, such guns, knifes, screwdriver, a bottle, a pencil, a car, rock, unloaded gun or
1People v. Page (2004) 123 C.A.4th 1466, 1472, 20 C.R.3d 857
2In re Brandon T. (2011) 191 C.A.4th 1491, 1497, 120 C.R.3d 637
3People v. Russell (1943) 59 C.A.2d 660, 665, 139 P.2d 661
even a dog. Thus, it is considered a deadly weapon an object or instrument that could cause great bodily harm to another person. Further, all objects that could be used in a way to cause harm to the body, also including any part of the body, for instance, feet and hands could be included under this category.
Great Bodily Harm
Great bodily harm is characterized as a substantial physical harm or injury of another person. The standard for substantial physical harm is established when the injury is greater than a minor harm. This definition is subjective and vague, leaving different types of interpretation to a jury trial. However, it is usually understandable to jurors.
A willful as mentioned in the section of simple assault, is when a person is acting in a willful way, and the intention is to do something on purpose, however, there is no intent to hurt someone, gain advantage or break the law.
For example: Samantha and Joseph are married and they are having a fight inside their car. Samantha furious decided to get out and walk home. Joseph followed her with the car in a way that leads the witnesses to believe that he is trying to hit Samantha with the car.
In this case, even though Joseph did not intent to hit Samantha with the car, the could be charged of assault with deadly weapon because of how he followed her.
Awareness of the conduct
Another element that prosecution must prove in court is the awareness requirement. This element is satisfied when the defendant was aware that the act could lead to the application of force. Thus, the awareness element is hard to prove, since it is difficult to show in court the intention of the defendant's act.
Kelly and Patrick are having an argument in the middle of the street. Kelly pulled out a gun and started to shoot the ground to intimidate Patrick.
In this example, Kelly did not intent to hurt or cause a great bodily injury to Patrick, however, Kelly was aware that his action with a deadly weapon could cause a harm and injury Patrick. Thus, Kelly could be charged with assault with deadly weapon.
Assault with a deadly weapon in California is considered a wobbler, with a misdemeanor sentence of one year and as a felony sentence of two, three or four years.
The offense of assault with a deadly weapon can be charged as either misdemeanor or a felony, depending on the facts of each case. That is called wobbler in California, the prosecution has a option to charge the defendant with felony or misdemeanor. To determinate how the prosecution is going to charge each case, it must be considered the following factors:
- the type of weapon that it was used.
- if the victim suffered a great bodily injury
- the level of the injury
- who the victim was, whether the victim is a protected person, such as a police office, it might be charged as a felony.
If the factors are probate to be considered a misdemeanor crime and the deadly weapon was not a firearm. The misdemeanor assault with deadly weapon is punishable by a fine not exceeding one thousand dollars ($ 1,000) or by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding one year, or by both fine and imprisonment.
On the other hand, if the prosecution decides that the facts of the case is a felony and the deadly weapon used was not a firearm, the penalties might include a felony probation, not exceeding 4 years of imprisonment and by a fine not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($ 10,000).
Assault with deadly weapon - with a firearm
The California rules treat an assault with a firearm differently than an assault with deadly weapon, it will be include an additional penalty of a minimum 6 months of imprisonment. However, if the crime was committed with a semi-automatic firearm, the crime will be considered a felony, in which the imprisonment could be increased from three (3) to nine (9) years.
This type of assault will always be charged as a felony if the conduct was made with machine guns, assault weapons, or 50 BMG rifles, in this case an additional charge could be increased from four (4) to twelve (12) years of imprisonment.
Assault with a deadly weapon - on a law enforcement official or a firefighter
Under California Law, there is an aggravated penalty if the victim is a government enforcement or firefighter, in which is performing his duty while the crime occurred. This special rules is applied when the defendant knows or must have known that the victim was on-duty. Thus, this type of crime is always considered a felony in California. However, when the defendant did not use a firearm while committing the crime, the punishment is going to vary from three (3) to five (5) years in a state county jail depending on each case and factors.
However, If the crime was committed with a firearm, the following will be applied, it is going to vary depending on the type of firearm used. For ordinary firearm the penalty is going to be established from four (4) to eight (8) years. But if the crime was committed with semi-automatic firearm, the punishment is going to be established from five (5) to nine (9) years of imprisonment. And for aggravated crimes committed with machine gun, assault weapon, or 50 BMG rifle, the penalty could be established from six (6) to twelve (12) years in a state county jail.
Assault with Deadly Weapon - California's "Three Strikes" Law
In California there is an aggravate rule that it is called three strikes law, in which the judge has discretion to determine to increase or diminish the conviction depending on the defendant's record. For instance, if a defendant receive a "strike" on his record, by that is convicted with a felony and then after a while he receives another sentence with felony, the judge could give twice of the regular sentence in the conviction. And if the defendant gets three "strikes", he or she might give a 25 years of imprisonment in a California State prison. To determine if the assault counts as a strike in California, the following factors must be prove:
- The defendant caused a great bodily injury to the victim; and
- The victim was a protected person, as a police officer or firefighter; and
- The defendant used a firearm to commit the crime.
Legal Defenses that San Diego Criminal Attorney might build for you
In California Criminal Law, a person that committed an assault with deadly weapon could face hard punishment, since the crime is considered a felony, but it is going to vary case by case. However, San Diego Criminal Attorney can provide support and we can built the best legal defense as possible.
An assault with a deadly weapon is a felony crime in California Law, if a person is convicted with this type of crime, the crime is going to be on the person's criminal records. If you are looking for a job and the employer does a criminal background check and there is a assault offense registered, it is likely that the employer won't hire someone with a felony background. If you were charged with assault with a deadly weapon or firearm, you should promptly look for a Lawyer. San Diego Criminal Attorney has a great deal of success defending our clients and it can help you to build legal defenses that it could be use to contest these types of charges. If you would like more information, please contact our successful our staff to help you with your legal problems.
To contest the charges of assault with deadly weapon, San Diego Criminal Attorney would be able to use the following legal defenses: (1) the person did not use a weapon or means of force that would likely to cause injury to another person, (2) there was a self-defense action, (3) there was not intent to cause harm, (4) False accusation.
- There was no uses of deadly weapon or means to inflict force that would likely to cause injury to the victim:
If you did not use a deadly weapon or did not use a inflict force to another person that would likely cause serious injury, or the instrument used does not have the ability to inflict danger to another person. Thus, there is a possible legal defenses to avoid the charges of assault with a deadly weapon, you should contact the San Diego Criminal Attorney for a consultation.
- The conduct was in self-defense or third party defense:
The self-defense theory could be applied in assault with deadly weapon charges if the client reasonably believe that there was an imminent danger of suffering body injury or has being touched unlawfully. And there is a reasonable believe that an immediate use of force was necessary to avoid the dangers. And the uses of force was reasonable necessary to defend against the danger. If there was the case that you used a deadly weapon, to protect yourself, you should immediately contact San Diego Criminal Attorney. A self-defense strategy defense could be used against this type of charges, if there was the scenario. CALCRIM 3470
- There was no required intent or willful conduct.
Someone times the actions of the defendant were accidental or misunderstanding by the victim. Under this type of defense, it is essential that the defense attorney and the prosecution get the entire facts of the accident.
If you have been charged with assault with deadly weapon, make sure you contact an attorney immediately. San Diego Criminal Attorney can help you build a strong defense, if you did not act willfully.
- Wrongfully accused
Under the rules of Californa Law, it is too easy for a victim falsely accuse another of committing this crime, sometimes the cause of action is out of anger, revenge or jealousy. However, San Diego Criminal Attorney know how to protect its clients from wrongfully accusations. If this is your case, contact an attorney promptly.